Here is my (very rough) analysis of two photos that seem very much the same but on closer analysis seem to show a challenging combination of both identical similarities and unlikely differences. One photograph is from a book I have published 1912. The other is from the internet. I honestly think there are “problems” with the existence of these two photographs. I apologise for the crudity of my analysis and presentation (I go on a bit I know) but I have felt compelled to share this since I first came across the photographs. Please tell me what you think. I hope you find it as curious as I do.